<
Effective Mass of a Galaxy. Source galaxy artwork retained. Owner-approved current modeled-speed notation and conditional bound-mass interpretation. Published NGC 3198 SPARC data replace unidentified plotted points.

Effective Mass of a Galaxy

Realized Galaxy Dynamics and the MQ Effective-Mass Construction. Measurement Quantization, MQ, describes a realized response to a specified Newtonian baryonic source. The large spiral-galaxy image is representative artwork; it is not identified as an image of NGC 3198.

MQ realization law

R denotes positive galactocentric radius, in metres when evaluating SI equations. g_bar is the positive Newtonian baryonic circular acceleration and g_real the realized acceleration, both in metres per square second. The positive scale a_MQ is the galactic acceleration scale.

greal(R)=gbar(R)1−exp[−gbar(R)aMQ]

The nonnegative realized circular speed v_real, in metres per second in these equations, follows circular kinematics.

vreal(R)=Rgreal(R)

The scale uses exact speed of light c, in metres per second, System Frame expansion frequency H_sys converted to inverse seconds, and dimensionless MQ coefficient theta_si. The current calculation gives a_MQ = 1.20037(33) times ten to the minus ten metres per square second.

aMQ=cHsys2θsi−1

Identified galaxy rotation curve

The graph shows every published SPARC NGC 3198 row, with its supplied rotation speed and uncertainty. Radius is logarithmic in kiloparsecs; velocity is in kilometres per second. Source distance is 13.8 megaparsecs. The baryonic circular field uses the SPARC signed gas, stellar disk and bulge contributions. Adopted stellar mass-to-light ratios at 3.6 micrometres are 0.50 solar mass per solar luminosity for the disk and 0.70 for the bulge; this galaxy has no nonzero tabulated bulge contribution. Negative component velocities retain their outward-force sign through V times absolute V. At each supplied radius, the resulting positive baryonic circular acceleration is passed through the displayed MQ law. No parameters are fitted. Curves connect calculations at the supplied radii without extrapolation. The red curve is a conditional fixed-source comparison, not a fit or a statistical validation. The velocity axis extends below zero to display the innermost published symmetric uncertainty without truncation. Plotted error bars are the published velocity uncertainties, not a total uncertainty model for the MQ curve. Distance, inclination, mass-to-light and model uncertainties are not varied.

Primary data and mass-model prescription are SPARC, Lelli, McGaugh and Schombert, Astronomical Journal 152, 157 (2016), DOI 10.3847/0004-6256/152/6/157. Published data are at https://astroweb.case.edu/SPARC/Rotmod_LTG.zip.

Conditional effective-mass construction

This separate construction uses bound mass M_b and intermediate effective-mass parameter M_e, in kilograms. Bound mass is distinct from reconstructed baryonic mass. The supplied modeled speed v_m and bound speed v_b are positive physical speeds in metres per second. In the source, R is positive, v_b is positive, and v_m is at least half v_b so the effective mass is nonnegative.

Me=Mb(2vmvb−1)

The formula follows MQ2480. It is an adopted mass-scaling construction conditional on the modeled speed and bound prescription, not the circular-speed inversion of an arbitrary observed rotation curve. The effective speed generated by that mass is separately defined in MQ2484; equality with the modeled or observed speed is an additional condition. No equality of these two constructions or fit of the effective-mass parameter to the SPARC curve is asserted. The bound-mass circular-speed inversion has an enclosed-mass interpretation only in spherical Newtonian geometry; an actual galactic disk requires its field. Equations are unnumbered.

Infographic viewer

100% of fit

Drag or pinch within the drawing. With the viewing area focused, use arrow keys to pan, + or − to zoom, and 0 or Home to fit. Escape closes. Resizing refits the drawing. The controls offer the same actions without gestures.

Effective Mass of a Galaxy

Measurement Quantization (MQ) approaches galactic orbital dynamics by retaining the Newtonian calculation of the baryonic gravitational field while changing how the gravitational response is realized as that field enters the low-acceleration regime. In this construction, the additional gravitating mass ordinarily inferred from a galaxy’s rotation curve is not introduced as a separate material component. The effective-mass parameter developed below is a conditional MQ construction and must be distinguished from the Newtonian mass inferred directly from a realized velocity.[1]

MQ starts from the single axiom “measure is discrete.” Its logical construction concerns count relationships. The Internal Frame is the primitive count domain. The System Frame is the relational realization of encoded geometry and observable measures. The Frames mapping specifies how primitive count configurations yield realized observables. Within this architecture, physical reference measures realize the underlying count relationships; the galactic law uses the expansion rate in the System Frame. The four inputs identified for fundamental-measure and constant reconstruction are the fine-structure constant, the speed of light, electron mass, and Bohr radius. They select and normalize a physical realization. They are not four additional axioms or necessarily four statistically independent measurements. Cosmic microwave background temperature separately selects the epoch in the adopted age prescription, and galaxy applications also require baryonic-source data.[2]

MQ does not propose that its effective-mass parameter is additional matter distributed through a galaxy. The local gravitational realization uses the baryonic source. The broader relation to the galactic mass discrepancy is discussed on the Dark Matter page. The conditional effective-mass construction and the galactic realization law have different inputs; their relationship must be assessed without identifying their mass parameters by definition.[1]

Baryonic Acceleration and the MQ Realization

For a spherical baryonic source, let Mbar(R) be the enclosed baryonic mass in kg, R the galactocentric radius in m, gbar the inward Newtonian baryonic acceleration in m s−2, and G the upper-count gravitational coupling in m3 kg−1 s−2. Then

gbar(R)=GMbar(R)R2

The associated Newtonian circular speed vNew(R), in m s−1, is

vNew(R)=GMbar(R)R

These enclosed-mass formulas require spherical geometry. For a galactic disk, the Newtonian field must instead be calculated from the actual mass distribution, with source components combined using their physical signs.[1]

The galactic acceleration scale aMQ, in m s−2, is related to the speed of light c, in m s−1, the epoch-specific expansion rate Hsys in the System Frame, in s−1, and the dimensionless invariant coefficient θsi by

aMQ=cHsys2θsi−1

The present-epoch conditional calculation gives aMQ = 1.20037(33) × 10−10 m s−2. Parenthetical digits indicate one standard uncertainty in the last quoted digits. This propagates the stated calibration and temperature inputs with the age prescription held fixed; it excludes uncertainty in the absolute temporal normalization and unquantified model discrepancy. The galaxy statistics reported below used the frozen nominal value 1.20040492178 × 10−10 m s−2 and were not rerun at the revised value. This scale is fixed upstream of the individual galaxy rotation-curve comparisons.[3]

MQ defines the dimensionless realization depth χ by

χ=gbar(R)aMQ

The corresponding dimensionless realization fraction P(R) is

P(R)=1−exp[−gbar(R)aMQ]

For positive inward baryonic acceleration and a positive acceleration scale, the realized gravitational acceleration greal(R), in m s−2, is

greal(R)=gbar(R)1−exp[−gbar(R)aMQ]

The realized circular speed vreal(R), in m s−1, follows directly

vreal(R)=vNew(R)1−exp[−gbar(R)aMQ]

This construction preserves the Newtonian calculation of the baryonic source field. When gbar is large compared with aMQ, the exponential term vanishes in the limit and greal approaches gbar. As gbar decreases relative to aMQ, the realized response increasingly departs from the baryonic Newtonian value. Recovering the source field in the high-acceleration limit is a consistency result for this law. The local derivation also assumes the stated quadratic spatial norm, circular kinematics, and subdivision-consistent composition of unrealized availability.[3]

From Velocity Difference to Effective Mass

The effective-mass construction uses the specified modelled speed vm, the bound speed vb, and the effective speed ve, each in m s−1. The bound mass Mb and effective-mass parameter Me are in kg. Bound mass is distinct from reconstructed baryonic mass. The dimensionless relative velocity difference Δf(vm) is defined by[1]

Δf(vm)=vm−vbvb=vmvb−1

MQ adopts the following mass-scaling relation. Its adoption is a separate step from defining the relative velocity difference.

Me=Mb(2Δf(vm)+1)=Mb(2vmvb−1)

The bound mass is specified through the classical circular-speed inversion

Mb=Rvb2G

These relations require R > 0 and vb > 0. Nonnegative effective mass requires vm ≥ vb/2. Interpreting the circular-speed inversion as enclosed physical mass requires spherical Newtonian geometry. A disk needs its actual gravitational field.[1]

When vm = vb, the relative velocity difference vanishes and Me = Mb. When vm exceeds vb, Me exceeds Mb. These are algebraic consequences of the adopted mass-scaling relation; they do not identify bound mass with the baryonic source or establish an independently predicted rotation curve.

Substitution into the Newtonian circular-orbit relation gives the corresponding effective orbital speed

ve=GMeR=GMbR(2vmvb−1)

Effective mass is therefore derived from the adopted bound and modelled speeds. It is not an independent extra inventory of matter. It is also not generally the direct Newtonian inverse mass obtained from the realized speed in the preceding galactic law. Equating these constructions would require an additional demonstrated relation between their inputs. If the modelled speed is taken from the target observations, the resulting mass transformation is not an independent prediction of those observations.[1]

Why Galactic Rotation Curves Become Approximately Flat

The exterior weak-acceleration limit of the galactic realization law has a separate consequence. For a finite isolated baryonic source with a monopole exterior field, let Mbar without a radius argument denote its limiting total baryonic mass. The exact asymptotic relation is

limR→∞Rgreal(R)=GMbaraMQ

Circular motion gives vreal2(R) = R greal(R), so

limR→∞vreal4(R)=GMbaraMQ

The realized orbital speed thus approaches a radius-independent value in the exterior weak-acceleration limit. Approximately flat rotation curves and the fourth-power relation between asymptotic speed and baryonic mass follow from this law under the stated conditions. The limiting speed depends on the source mass; it is not one universal speed for all galaxies.[3]

A spherical Newtonian interpretation of the enhanced realized speed infers more gravitating mass than is present in the baryonic source model. That inference is a useful mass-equivalent description, but it must not be identified automatically with the conditional Me construction above.

Comparison with Galactic Observations

The current MQ analysis applies the same fixed galactic realization law to two observationally distinct constructions. One compares a specified Milky Way baryonic source with an externally reconstructed rotation curve. The other applies the law across all 175 galaxies in the published SPARC catalog. These tests concern the galactic realization law, rather than a direct empirical test of the conditional effective-mass construction.[4]

For the principal Milky Way comparison, the baryonic source is reconstructed from McMillan’s bulge, thin- and thick-stellar disks, H I disk, and molecular-gas disk. The dark halo force is excluded before applying the MQ law. The Eilers circular velocities supply the kinematic target and are not fitted by adjusting an MQ acceleration parameter. McMillan fitted baryonic and halo parameters jointly using Galactic dynamical constraints, while Eilers inferred the target curve through axisymmetric Jeans modelling. Separate reconstructions do not establish statistical independence.[4][5][6]

Across the 38 Eilers radii, the MQ preprint reports a baryonic Newtonian root-mean-square (RMS) residual of 69.03 km s−1. Applying the fixed law reduces it to 8.90 km s−1, a reduction of approximately 87.1%. The mean absolute error (MAE) is 7.43 km s−1, and the mean signed residual is −3.07 km s−1.[4]

For the specified McMillan conditional source-covariance propagation, the reported generalized chi-square statistic is 39.57 for 38 degrees of freedom, with a right-tail probability of 0.400. The calculation varies the thin-disk, thick-disk, and bulge normalizations while holding scale lengths and other source parameters fixed. The diagonal total-error treatment instead gives chi-square 689.831 and a right-tail probability of 1.26 × 10−120, formally rejecting the complete sample under that error model.[4]

The full Eilers point-to-point observational covariance and complete McMillan posterior have not been jointly propagated in this comparison. The non-rejection is conditional on the specified covariance model and is not a covariance-complete likelihood test. The probability value is not the probability that MQ is correct.[4]

The broader population test retains all 175 published SPARC galaxies and 3,366 radial measurements before subdivision by assigned observational quality or galaxy properties. “Complete SPARC” refers to this published catalog, not a volume-limited or statistically complete census of galaxies.[4][7]

The same fixed law is applied without a galaxy-specific MQ acceleration parameter. The preprint reports a point-weighted signed residual of +0.02644 km s−1, a ratio of mean realized to mean observed velocity of 1.00019, pooled MAE of 16.20 km s−1, and pooled RMS residual of 22.82 km s−1.[4]

The near-zero pooled signed residual indicates close catalog-wide normalization, but does not imply point-by-point agreement. The 3,366 measurements are nested within 175 galaxies. Source reconstructions retain uncertainties in stellar mass-to-light ratios, distance, inclination, gas distributions, and baryonic decomposition. The full catalog also retains a significant velocity-dependent normalization residual under simultaneous quality and property controls, with strong velocity–luminosity collinearity. These diagnostics do not establish a unique physical explanation for the residuals.[4]

The reported comparisons test the scale and structure of circular velocities under the adopted source models, calibration, and epoch prescription. The improved Milky Way residual and near-unity pooled SPARC normalization have different evidential roles. The cited statistics are author-reported results, not a new reanalysis here, and no matched comparison selecting MQ over conventional halo models or other gravitational prescriptions is performed on this page.[4]

Physical Interpretation

The galactic realization law begins with a baryonic source, calculates its Newtonian field, and predicts a circular response through the fixed realization associated with the Frames mapping. Its high-acceleration limit recovers the source field, while its finite-source exterior weak-acceleration limit yields a radius-independent limiting speed and the baryonic fourth-power relation.[3]

The effective-mass parameter Me belongs to the conditional bound-speed and modelled-speed construction. It is not an independently distributed additional material component. Keeping this parameter distinct from the Newtonian inverse mass of the galactic realization preserves what each construction actually establishes. Rotation-curve comparisons test the latter law within their source and uncertainty assumptions; lensing, cluster dynamics, and cosmological dark-matter constraints require their own tests.[1][4]

Source Notes

[1] Conditional effective mass. Jody A. Geiger, Effective Mass of a Galaxy, Star Velocity and their Relation, public author preprint, 2026, Sections 1 and 3, especially the relative velocity difference, adopted mass scaling, and circular-speed inversion; Section 4 for the separate observational-test requirement. The modelled speed is an input. This paper does not itself fit a measured rotation curve.

[2] Foundations and input roles. Jody A. Geiger, author clarification of the logical count foundation and physical realization (2 November 2026), unpublished author statement, custodian Informativity Institute. This statement is not publicly accessible and establishes intended architecture and input roles, not independent empirical validation. Frame definitions are also given in the public preprint in note [1]. See the public fundamental-expression discussion for background. The four-input scope is fundamental-measure and constant reconstruction; the exact SI speed of light also supplies a unit convention.

[3] Local law and conditional scale. Jody A. Geiger, Galactic Rotation and Dark Matter in Measurement Quantization, public author preprint, 2026, Section 3 for the scale, source law and limits. The quoted uncertainty is conditional on its epoch prescription. The exponential functional form previously appeared as an empirical relation in S. S. McGaugh, F. Lelli and J. M. Schombert, Radial Acceleration Relation in Rotationally Supported Galaxies, Physical Review Letters 117, 201101 (2016), DOI 10.1103/PhysRevLett.117.201101. MQ’s claim concerns its derivation and upstream normalization; sharing a functional shape is not an independent test of that derivation.

[4] Reported galaxy comparisons. Jody A. Geiger, A First Principles Derivation of the Galactic Radial Acceleration Relation from Measurement Quantization, public author preprint, 2026, Section 4.3 and Table 9 for the Milky Way covariance tests; Section 4.4 for pooled SPARC statistics; Sections 4.5–4.9 for population controls; Table 12 for the comparison summary. These are author-reported numerical comparisons, not independent replications. The galaxy data and covariance propagation were not rerun for this page.

[5] Milky Way kinematic target. Anna-Christina Eilers, David W. Hogg, Hans-Walter Rix and Melissa K. Ness, The Circular Velocity Curve of the Milky Way from 5 to 25 kpc, Astrophysical Journal 871(1), 120 (2019), DOI 10.3847/1538-4357/aaf648. This paper supplies the kinematic reconstruction, not the MQ residual calculation.

[6] Milky Way source model. Paul J. McMillan, The mass distribution and gravitational potential of the Milky Way, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 465(1), 76–94 (2017), DOI 10.1093/mnras/stw2759. Its source parameters were jointly fitted within a baryonic-plus-halo model; omitting the halo force does not remove that provenance.

[7] SPARC catalog. Federico Lelli, Stacy S. McGaugh and James M. Schombert, SPARC: Mass Models for 175 Disk Galaxies with Spitzer Photometry and Accurate Rotation Curves, Astronomical Journal 152(6), 157 (2016), DOI 10.3847/0004-6256/152/6/157. The catalog supplies observational reconstructions and source assumptions; the MQ comparison is reported separately in note [4].


Related Journalist Briefs


Browse published MQ papers

Double-click to edit...